Tuesday, December 15, 2009

The narcissism of small Liberal and Tory differences

This kind of thing has become sadly predictable. But, reassuringly, not so predictable that it doesn’t merit the criticism it is receiving.

In fairness, let’s first acknowledge that Canadian politics has always been home to its share of baseless and tasteless attacks. But let’s also accept that recent years have also witnessed a spike in both the number and viciousness of childish political attacks – particularly between the Liberal and Conservative teams.

Who can forget these rhetorical high-points? ...

Conservatives forced to remove image of bird defecating on Liberal leader

Conservatives accuse Liberal MP of bring “anti-Israel”

Liberal MP apologizes for calling Conservative MP “fat”

Liberal MP calls Conservative an “idiot" who should "go back to making tea"

Liberals demand apology for Prime Minister’s slur (Incredibly, Liberals made this their lead in question period for about a week, if memory serves)

So, why has debate between the Liberals and Conservatives become so poisonous that a photo of the PM being gunned down is deemed “okay” by the professional communications staff running the Liberal website?

Consider this: Speaking about student politics at the University of Toronto, the Old Bob Rae once famously opined that “the reason it was so acrimonious and so divisive is because the stakes were just so low.”

In other words, when what you are debating are matters of such small difference – bringing in the HST tomorrow or next week; appointing 17 Senators instead of 18; torture versus “torture-lite” – the tone of the debate becomes the only thing you actually control.

Unlike New Democrats who can put real differences on the table between them and Stephen Harper, Liberals find relief in the ad-hominem. It’s all they have left.

4 comments:

Rick Barnes said...

Its the white spotted black cats vs black spotted white cats. Seems to me they are just a different colour most of the time.

855 said...

我從來不認為不同意我的看法就是冒犯..................................................

GarthStich said...

熟女真命苦換妻俱樂部線上看a片台灣情色a片子安心亞寫真top1069拓網交友做愛自拍免費情色影片性感美女518人力銀行免費視訊twaricwwwtw2sexcom阿性情趣用品真人情趣娃娃援交友聊天室情色sexsuncom美女聊天室視訊聊天申請加盟qq聊天室funnysexygame080aa片

nitroglycol said...

I always like to say that the main difference between the two parties is that the Conservatives have more bigots, and the Liberals have more crooks.